Mills Teacher Scholars' inquiry work supports teachers to understand both what students are doing/thinking/learning and what is that they want students to do/ learn/think. Kirsti Jewel Peters’ exploration of academic discussion is a wonderful illustration of how teachers need time and support to make sense of complex concepts (academic discussion, balanced literacy, technology integration, critical analysis) on their own terms in order to effectively guide students to deeper learning. On her journey of incorporating academic discussion into her classroom, Kirsti starts with passing along tools to her students that were passed to her, yet through her Mills Teacher Scholars inquiry work explores the central--but often over looked-- question: What do I mean by academic discussion?
What are we talking about when we say "academic discussion?"
The Common Core State Standards are here, and we teachers are trying to wrap our minds around how they’ll shift our teaching and our students’ learning experiences. There are gripes about the shift, confusion about what’s so different, and some praise that we’re not glued to past curriculum. Curriculum has been purchased across districts and professional developments are in session. Teachers are preparing themselves to take on the CCSS with excitement, some uncertainty, and a little bit of optimism.
Meanwhile, I’m in East Oakland, trying to figure out what this nationwide shift will do to and for my students. One of the big takeaways from OUSD’s discussion of the CCSS, is that, regardless of what you’re teaching, you must support your students’ usage of academic discussion. Academic discussion should be used in E.L.A! Math! Science! Art!
Sounds easy enough, right? Simply, teach your students (from K-12) about any given topic, and have them discuss it… with absolute sophistication.
Unfortunately, when beginning my inquiry around academic discussion in math, the simplicity of the task was lost on me. I kept wondering, what is academic discussion? Is it using jargon words associated with certain fields of study? Is it speaking in complete sentences? Does it mean using a British accent, and having your pinky in the air?